Find Your Ride, Without the Hidden Fees
CarGuys Auto offers a full range of vehicles — from budget-friendly economy cars to premium rides — at honest, upfront prices. No surprise charges, no fine print games. Just a straightforward rental experience.
6K + Customers
has used our renting services
How It Works
Booking a car rental is a straightforward process that typically involves the following steps
1. Choose Locations
Browse our fleet, from economy cars to luxury vehicles, and pick the one that fits your trip and your budget.
2. Pick-Up Locations
Select your pickup and return dates and confirm your location in the Middleburg Heights / greater Cleveland area.
3. Book your Car
Reserve online or give us a call at (440) 768-3575. Bring a valid driver's license and you're ready to go — no hidden fees, ever.
Explore Most Popular Cars
From everyday economy cars to luxury rides, we've got a vehicle for every trip and every budget.
Facts By The Numbers
100 +
Happy Customers
50 +
Count of Cars
25 K+
Car Center Solutions
20 K+
Total Kilometer
Why Choose Us
We believe renting a car should be simple, fair, and affordable.
Honest, Upfront Pricing
What you see is what you pay. No hidden fees, no last-minute add-ons, no surprises at pickup or drop-off.
Better Rates Than the Big Guys
We keep our overhead low so we can offer competitive daily rates without cutting corners on vehicle quality.
Local & Personal Service
As a Middleburg Heights–based business, we know our customers by name — not by a ticket number
What People say about us?
Discover what our customers have think about us
Lucas Moquin
CarGuys Auto made the entire rental process incredibly easy. The pricing was clear from the beginning, with no surprise fees when I picked up the car. The vehicle was clean, reliable, and exactly what I needed. I’ll definitely rent from them again.
Rabien Ustoc
I had a great experience with CarGuys Auto. The staff was friendly, professional, and made the whole process quick and stress-free. It’s refreshing to deal with a local company that actually cares about its customers.
Valerie L. Ellis
We needed an SUV for a family trip and CarGuys Auto had exactly what we were looking for. The vehicle was comfortable, clean, and dependable. Everything from booking to drop-off went smoothly.
Laverne Marier
I needed an affordable car for a few days and was impressed with both the price and the quality of the vehicle. No confusing charges or unnecessary complications. CarGuys Auto made renting a car exactly as easy as it should be.
Sydney Salmons
From the moment I booked my vehicle, the team at CarGuys Auto was helpful and responsive. The car was in great condition and the pickup and return process was fast and convenient. Highly recommended for anyone looking for a reliable local rental company.
Frequently Asked Questions
Find answers to your questions from our previous answers
How old do I need to be to rent a car?
Most renters must be at least 21 years old, though requirements can vary by vehicle type. Contact us to confirm eligibility for the vehicle you're interested in.
What documents do I need to rent a car?
You'll need a valid driver's license, proof of identity, and a credit or debit card for payment. Additional ID or age verification may apply.
What types of vehicles are available for rent?
We offer economy and compact cars, sedans, SUVs, and select luxury vehicles to fit a range of needs and budgets.
Can I rent a car with a debit card?
Yes — debit cards are accepted, though a security hold may apply. A valid driver's license is required at pickup.
Can I add additional drivers to my rental agreement?
Yes — additional drivers can be added and must meet the same license and age requirements as the primary renter.